My Charmin charms came yesterday! Yay! Carol had made a pink one first, then I found a pic of a blue package of Charmin, so she made a blue one as well. I just thought the blue one would look better on the pin. She sent both charms to me. I put the blue one on the boxers pin, and put the pink one on a silver chain. hehe!
So, now, the now once again four-charmed boxers pin, with new Charmin charm:

The charm is a little bigger than I expected, but I think it looks ok with how I have the rest of the charms spaced.
I will once again explain the pin, and the six *yes, six!* songs it represents.
1. The boxers represent OMM, of course.
2. The waffle iron print on the boxers represents Waffle King
3. The Charmin charm represents DTBS
4. The jar of Cheese Whiz represents "Satan Eats Cheese Whiz", the backwards message on "Nature Trail to Hell"
5. The Froot Loops represent "Cheerios, Apple Jacks, Cheerios"
6. The Doritos represent IAATP
Here is my new Charmin necklace:

That charm is slightly bigger than the blue one. It only looks smaller because of the image size being adjusted smaller. I like the necklace idea.
Thanks so much, Carol!